The Kardashev Scale

Return to Tangent's Shared Notes
(I am currently in danger of becoming homeless. If you can spare a few dollars, it would help a lot. PayPal.me/Guard13007)

The Kardashev Scale

The Kardashev Scale is a logarithmic rating for a civilization's development or technology, used to hypothesize about alien civilizations or make predictions about our own future advancement.

Kurzgesagt Cool Worlds
Isaac Arthur

Modified Kardashev Scale, based on Watts:
In case the above formatting is broken: K = (log(W) - 7.38) / 9.73

  • Nuclear, solar -> only ways to Type I1
  • Heat dissipation becomes a huge issue for Type I civilization, inevitably.1 Regardless of the greenhouse effect, any planet increasing its energy use must get hotter.
  • Solar power on earth is limited by the Carnot Limit to ~68.7% efficiency.1 A more realistic limit is 30% efficiency.
  • The Kardashev Scale
    • Based on this, I propose population scales and a modified Kardashev Scale for local governments/systems/collections of systems. Of course.. that doesn't apply as well with FTL travel being commonplace.
  • Another reference, with pretty animations: What Do Alien Civilizations Look Like? The Kardashev Scale by Kurzgesagt

Isaac Arthur on the Kardashev Scale

Notes

Notes

  • Energy may not be the best measure, because efficiency is increased with technological progress.
  • Carl Sagan's Modified Kardashev Scale:
    • K0: 106 W
    • K1: 1016 W
    • K2: 1026 W
    • K3: 1036 W
  • Power levels should be measured as electricity, otherwise a 200-acre farm is a K0.2 civilization, a single person's survival needs make them a K0.3, and earth is already a K1.
  • Modifying Sagan's scale to represent population may be better: 1 = 1010, 2 = 1020, etc.
  • A person's needs can reasonably assumed to require a megawatt of power.
  • By the time a civilization even gets close to K2, they'll be so separated as to not realistically be one civilization.
  • Without FTL capability, you do not get to K3.
  • K2-3 civilizations can move galaxies with galactic Shkadov Thrusters.
  • K5 would be the observable universe being used as energy, and is only possible with FTL capability, multiversal access, or breaking laws of physics.

Share Note for Obsidian 🌓